| Name | Graduation year | College |
|---|---|---|
| Nate Roth | 2018 | Kaskaskia College |
| Levi Davis | 2017 | Kaskaskia College |
| Brock Irwin | 2015 | Southern Illinois University - Edwardsville |
| Zach Tate | 2014 | Rend Lake College |
| Aaron Ruckman | 2013 | Hannibal LaGrange |
| Alex Phillips | 2013 | Hannibal LaGrange |
| Pete Colclasure | 2012 | Lindenwood |
| John Tolliver | 2012 | McKendree University |
| Logan Phillips | 2012 | Hannibal LaGrange |
| Monte Ferrero | 2012 | Millikin University |
| Kameron Wilkin | 2012 | Millikin University |
| Jared Storment | 2011 | Greenville College |
| Jeff Tolliver | 2011 | McKendree University |
| Daniel Childress | 2010 | Kaskaskia College |
| Gavin Petrea | 2009 | University of Indianapolis |
| Logan Bolton | 2009 | Millikin University |
| Patrick Flanagan | 2008 | Bradley University |
| Josh Lusch | 2007 | Millikin University |
| Tyson Moore | 2006 | McKendree University |
| Ben Strother | 2005 | Hannibal LaGrange |
| Scott Murfin | 2005 | Maryville University |
| Justin Green | 2004 | Olney Central |
| Tyson Mulvany | 2004 | Hannibal LaGrange |